Duke

Three takeaways from Duke football’s 17-10 Birmingham Bowl win over the Troy Trojans

Duke Blue Devils players and interim head coach Trooper Taylor celebrate with the Birmingham Bowl trophy after defeating the Troy Trojans in Birmingham, Ala. Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023.
Duke Blue Devils players and interim head coach Trooper Taylor celebrate with the Birmingham Bowl trophy after defeating the Troy Trojans in Birmingham, Ala. Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023. USA TODAY Sports

Through all the craziness of the last three weeks, with a coaching change, players transferring and injuries, the Duke Blue Devils stuck to their business and finished off a memorable season with a win.

With interim head coach Trooper Taylor leading them, the Blue Devils never trailed while posting a 17-10 Birmingham Bowl win over Troy on Saturday at Protective Stadium.

Selected to the Birmingham Bowl after head coach Mike Elko left to become head coach at Texas A&M, Duke (8-5) controlled the line of scrimmage all day to end Troy’s 10-game winning streak.

The Trojans (11-3) were looking to post the Sun Belt Conference’s first win over a Power 5 conference team in bowl play. Despite benefiting from two Duke turnovers while committing only one turnover themselves, the Trojans saw their potent running game stifled as the Blue Devils won the program’s fifth consecutive bowl game.

“We just heard the talk about how Troy was gonna play an ACC team and they didn’t really give us any credit and say they were about to play Duke,” Blue Devils junior running back Jaquez Moore said. “They were just focused on ACC. So were just looking to come out here and earn our respect.”

Moore personified what the Blue Devils have been through. He entered the transfer portal after Elko left but withdrew after new head coach Manny Diaz was hired. He rushed for a team-best 73 yards as the Blue Devils gained 147 yards on the ground.

Jordan Waters, who has already committed to transfer to N.C. State next season, gained 66 yards on 11 carries for the Blue Devils.

Together they helped the Blue Devils control the ball enough in the fourth quarter to protect their 17-3 lead and hold off the Trojans when a Jeremiah Lewis interception at midfield ended Troy’s final possession.

Duke Blue Devils defensive linemen Anthony Nelson (93) makes angels in the confetti after defeating the Troy Trojans at Protective Stadium on Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023.
Duke Blue Devils defensive linemen Anthony Nelson (93) makes angels in the confetti after defeating the Troy Trojans at Protective Stadium on Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023. Petre Thomas USA TODAY Sports

Here are three takeaways from Duke’s win:

Third downs play big role

Duke built its 14-0 halftime lead with solid play in crucial third-down situations on both sides of the ball, and that continued as the Blue Devils put the win away.

Troy failed on its first six third downs of the game and converted only one of its first nine.

The Trojans finished 2 of 12 on third downs while going 0 for 3 on fourth downs.

The Blue Devils’ defense kept making key plays. Duke finished with 10 pass breakups while also collecting five tackles for losses.

Defensive back Chandler Rivers led Duke in both categories with three pass breakups and two tackles for losses plus a quarterback hurry. He was named the Birmingham Bowl’s most valuable player.

“We played Duke football,” Rivers said. “We played as we’ve played all year. We found another energy. We found that edge because a lot of stuff [was] going on throughout the week. We found that edge, so that was that.”

Conversely, Duke converted five of its first eight third downs on offense over the first half. The Blue Devils failed on all four of their second-half conversions, allowing the Trojans to climb back into the game.

Duke Blue Devils defensive linemen Aeneas Peebles (16) sacks Troy Trojans quarterback Gunnar Watson (18) during their bowl game in Birmingham, Ala. Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023.
Duke Blue Devils defensive linemen Aeneas Peebles (16) sacks Troy Trojans quarterback Gunnar Watson (18) during their bowl game in Birmingham, Ala. Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023. Petre Thomas USA TODAY Sports

Controlling Vidal

Troy junior running back Kimani Vidal amassed 1,582 rushing yards this season, the second-most yards among Division I players entering the bowl games. He averaged 5.7 yards per carry and rushed for 14 touchdowns.

Duke’s defense, though, limited his explosiveness to stifle the Trojans’ offense.

Vidal finished with 79 yards on 17 carries, averaging 4.6 yards per carry. His longest run went for 12 yards.

“We knew we had to stop the run,” Duke graduate student defensive tackle DeWayne Carter said. “That was our priority. We took it upon ourselves as d-tackles to have a mentality game. We knew it was gonna stop the run to start with us up front.”

Duke Blue Devils running back Jaquez Moore (9) runs the ball during their bowl game against the Troy Trojans at Protective Stadium on Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023.
Duke Blue Devils running back Jaquez Moore (9) runs the ball during their bowl game against the Troy Trojans at Protective Stadium on Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023. Petre Thomas USA TODAY Sports

Big day for Pelino

For the second bowl game in a row, Todd Pelino tied a Duke record by booting three field goals.

He had three in last season’s 30-13 win over UCF in the Military Bowl to tie the record Ross Martin previously set at the 2015 Pinstripe Bowl.

Pelino booted three more field goals against Troy as the Blue Devils scored just one touchdown (with a two-point conversion) while scoring 17 points.

After joining Duke as a walk-on kicker before winning the place-kicking job last season, Pelino reveled in what the Blue Devils had accomplished given all the distractions.

“We came together as a team,” Pelino said “I feel like we bought into what we had to. We had one more game left and we were gonna come out here and show we’re a great football team. It’s the program to be in. It’s the place to be for everybody. We just came out here and did what we knew we could do.”

Duke Blue Devils running back Jordan Waters (7) runs the ball as Troy Trojans running back Tae Meadows (22) attempts to make the tackle during the Birmingham Bowl Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023.
Duke Blue Devils running back Jordan Waters (7) runs the ball as Troy Trojans running back Tae Meadows (22) attempts to make the tackle during the Birmingham Bowl Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023. Petre Thomas USA TODAY Sports

Here are earlier updates from the game:

Troy turns Duke turnover into TD

The Troy Trojans scored their first touchdown of the Birmingham Bowl on Derrick Graham’s 2-yard run to cut Duke’s lead to 17-10 with 5:54 left in the game.

The Trojans moved 87 yards to score after Duke missed an opportunity to create more distance on the scoreboard. Blue Devils quarterback Grayson Loftis saw his overthrown pass toward Sahmir Hagans intercepted by Troy’s Damaje Yancey at the Trojan 13.

Troy took advantage to get back in the game behind strong passing from Gunnar Watson. His biggest pass was a 30-yard pass to Payton Higgins that, combined with a roughing the passer penalty on Duke’s Aeneas Peebles, moved the Trojans to the Duke 8.

\Duke Blue Devils running back Jaylen Coleman (22) reacts after a touchdown run during the Blue Devils’ victory over the Troy Trojans in Birmingham, Ala., Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023.
\Duke Blue Devils running back Jaylen Coleman (22) reacts after a touchdown run during the Blue Devils’ victory over the Troy Trojans in Birmingham, Ala., Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023. Petre Thomas USA TODAY Sports

Pelino’s third FG extends Duke lead

Todd Pelino kicked his third field goal of the game from 45 yards, giving Duke a 17-3 lead over Troy with 13:29 to play in the fourth quarter.

Troy gets on the scoreboard

The Trojans ended Duke’s shutout bid when Scott Taylor Renfroe booted a 44-yard field goal with 1:36 left in the third quarter, cutting the Blue Devils’ lead to 14-3.

Halftime update

Duke’s solid play, particularly on third downs, on both sides of the ball helped the Blue Devils lead Troy 14-0 at halftime of the Birmingham Bowl.

The Blue Devils’ offense is 5 of 8 on third downs, helping them possess the ball for 18:17 of the first half. Troy, meanwhile, failed to gain a first down on all six of its third downs. The Trojans also failed on a fourth-down attempt.

Duke quarterback Grayson Loftis completed 13 of 21 first-half passes for 128 yards. Sahmir Hagans and Jordan Moore each caught four passes.

Troy gained just five first downs while rushing for 15 yards on 10 carries.

Duke Blue Devils quarterback Grayson Loftis (12) passes the ball during their game against the Troy Trojans in the Birmingham Bowl in Birmingham, Ala., Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023.
Duke Blue Devils quarterback Grayson Loftis (12) passes the ball during their game against the Troy Trojans in the Birmingham Bowl in Birmingham, Ala., Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023. Petre Thomas USA TODAY Sports

Pelino FG puts Duke up 14-0 at halftime

Todd Pelino’s second field goal, this one from 37 yards, extended Duke’s lead to 14-0 over Troy at halftime.

The Blue Devils dominated the second quarter, holding the ball for all but 27 seconds of the final 12:14 of the half. Duke’s final drive before halftime covered 64 yards and used 6:24 of game time. The Blue Devils converted four third-downs plays on the drive, three on Grayson Loftis passes and a fourth on a Jaylen Coleman run.

Pelino adds to Duke’s lead

Todd Pelino booted a 34-yard field goal with 6:51 left in the first half, giving Duke an 11-0 lead over Troy.

On a drive that started at the Duke 33, the Blue Devils converted a pair of third downs to move into Troy territory. The first conversion came on a third-and-13 play when Troy’s Reddy Steward was called for pass interference while guarding Duke wide receiver Jordan Moore.

From the Duke 47, Grayson Loftis completed a 12-yard pass to freshman Sean Brown on a third-and-8 play. It was Brown’s first career catch.

Loftis followed that with a 23-yard pass to Sahmir Hagans, moving Duke to the Troy 18.

Duke Blue Devils wide receiver Sahmir Hagans (2) reacts after making a reception for a first down during their bowl game against the Troy Trojans in Birmingham, Ala. Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023.
Duke Blue Devils wide receiver Sahmir Hagans (2) reacts after making a reception for a first down during their bowl game against the Troy Trojans in Birmingham, Ala. Saturday, Dec. 23, 2023. Petre Thomas USA TODAY Sports

Duke scores first

Jaylen Coleman’s 1-yard touchdown run with 2:29 to play in the first quarter gave Duke an 8-0 lead over Troy.

The score punctuated a 64-yard drive where running back Jaquez Moore carried three times for 29 yards. Duke quarterback Grayson Loftis set up the touchdown with a 26-yard pass to Jalon Calhoun on second-and-10 from the Troy 27.

Duke added the two-point conversion on a Nicky Dalmolin run.

Who’s in, who’s out

Duke knew it would be playing the Birmingham Bowl without quarterback Riley Leonard and defensive end RJ Oben, who are transferring to Notre Dame. Leonard is still recovering from the turf toe injury that required surgery to his left foot. Oben opted out of the game.

Linebacker Dorian Mausi, who is also in the transfer portal, did not play against Troy.

The Blue Devils had running back Jordan Waters, who will transfer to N.C. State next season.

Three injured starters — defensive back Brandon Johnson (upper body), left tackle Graham Barton (upper body) and right tackle Jake Hornibrook (upper body) — missed the game.

With Barton and Hornibrook out, redshirt freshman Brian Parker started at left tackle with redshirt freshman Matt Craycraft starting at right tackle.

Cam Bergeron started in place of Johnson at nickelback.

Duke’s starters at defensive end were redshirt freshman Wesley Williams and graduate student Anthony Nelson.

This story was originally published December 23, 2023 at 11:41 AM with the headline "Three takeaways from Duke football’s 17-10 Birmingham Bowl win over the Troy Trojans."

Steve Wiseman
The News & Observer
Steve Wiseman was named Raleigh News & Observer and Durham Herald-Sun sports editor in May 2025. He covered Duke athletics, beginning in 2010, prior to his current assignment. In the Associated Press Sports Editors national contest, he placed in the top 10 in beat writing in 2019, 2021 and 2022, breaking news in 2019, event coverage in 2025 and explanatory writing in 2018. Before coming to Durham in 2010, Steve worked for The State (Columbia, SC), Herald-Journal (Spartanburg, S.C.), The Sun Herald (Biloxi, Miss.), Charlotte Observer and Hickory (NC) Daily Record covering beats including the NFL’s Carolina Panthers and New Orleans Saints, University of South Carolina athletics and the S.C. General Assembly. He’s won numerous state-level press association awards. Steve graduated from Illinois State University in 1989. 
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER