Hersh: Military waging war with White House
3 months ago | 14793 views | 7 7 comments | 86 86 recommendations | email to a friend | print
By Neil Offen

noffen@heraldsun.com; 419-6646

DURHAM — The U.S. military is not just fighting wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, America’s most renowned investigative journalist says.

The army is also “in a war against the White House — and they feel they have [President] Obama boxed in,” Pulitzer Prize-winning reporter Seymour Hersh told several hundred people in Duke University’s Page Auditorium on Tuesday night. “They think he’s weak and the wrong color. Yes, there’s racism in the Pentagon. We may not like to think that, but it’s true and we all know it.”

In a speech on Obama’s foreign policy, Hersh, who uncovered the My Lai massacre during the Vietnam War and torture at Abu Ghraib prison during the Iraqi war, said many military leaders want Obama to fail.

“A lot of people in the Pentagon would like to see him get into trouble,” he said. By leaking information that the commanding officer in Afghanistan, Gen. Stanley McChrystal, says the war would be lost without an additional 40,000 American troops, top brass have put Obama in a no-win situation, Hersh contended.

“If he gives them the extra troops they’re asking for, he loses politically,” Hersh said. “And if he doesn’t give them the troops, he also loses politically.”

The journalist criticized the president for “letting the military do that,” and suggested the only way out was for Obama to stand up to them.

“He’s either going to let the Pentagon run him or he has to run the Pentagon,” Hersh said. If he doesn’t, “this stuff is going to be the ruin of his presidency.”

Hersh called the “Af-Pak” situation — the spreading conflict in Afghanistan and Pakistan — Obama’s main challenge.

The war in Afghanistan has destabilized Pakistan, which has 80 to 100 nuclear weapons, said Hersh, who recently returned from a visit to South Asia. “And the nuclear situation [in Pakistan] is more dire than you could know. It sucks.”

The only way for the U.S. to extricate itself from the conflict, Hersh said, is to negotiate with the Taliban.

“It’s the only way out,” he said. “I know that there’s a lot of discussion in the White House about this now. But Obama is going to have to take charge, and there’s no evidence he’s going to do that.”

While critical of the president on Afghanistan, Hersh, who travels to the Middle East three or four times a year, did praise his foreign policy initiatives toward Iran.

“When it comes to Iran, he’s changed the paradigm,” he said. “[President] Bush always said we’ll negotiate with those duty Iranians about their nuclear enrichment plans when they stop enriching nuclear material. Obama understands there is some room there to maneuver. That’s a huge change.”

He also praised Obama for also changing the paradigm with his decision to shelve plans for a missile defense system in Eastern Europe. Doing that, he said, would help U.S. relations with Russia.

“It’s about time we realize we have a lot in common with the Russians, like worrying about China and global terrorism,” Hersh said.

The missiles, he added, were just a continuation of the Cold War, and “it’s about time for us to capture some of the benefit we were supposed to get from ending the Cold War.”
comments (7)
« Ali_Lama wrote on Sunday, Nov 01 at 10:01 AM »
Sgt. LRRP Ret. wounded Vet. Afghanistan is where Nations' Armies, run by idiots, go to die! Read any historical account of foreign military in Afghanistan, then remove your moron head from your collective military/war making minded a** and negotiate a quick exit. To you "yahoo military morons"; it's scary knowing uninformed clowns, in military disguise, are carrying loaded weapons. One would think you had enough to do just keeping on your feet walking with those big floppy shoes, bar wasting brain power to talk out your fanny! To use a Republican 1st ladies words, "Just say NO!" to Nation building!
report abuse
« GySgt wrote on Wednesday, Oct 21 at 04:04 PM »
I'm one of the thousands of black veterans proud of our service to the country, and I'll personally vouch for the claim that there's racism in the military. There's racism in all society, though. Don't try to tell me that all those white southern officers are happy with a black Commander In Chief. But I'm sure they'll follow orders anyway.

President Obama gave us 23,000 more personnel for the Afghan theater within 2 weeks of taking office, which is a hell of a lot more than GWB did his last year. The poster who said people are dying while this "naif dithers" needs to remember that.

The problem in Afghanistan isn't whether we can beat the Taliban on the battlefield. The problem is whether the people are becoming the Taliban. The Taliban may look horrible to us, but to Afghans they might look like the lesser of two evils. The govt. in Afghanistan is so corrupt and ineffective a lot of people won't support it. The Taliban took over in the first place because of corruption in the Afghan government. The whole movement started as a reaction against a local warlord who regularly kidnapped and raped local girls. If the Afghan govt. doesn't get its act together we're just pouring our blood into the sand. So I for one am glad President Obama is taking the time to figure this out, I just hope he doesnt take too much longer.
report abuse
« freedom lover wrote on Monday, Oct 19 at 08:11 AM »
We can always depend on the military to keep ubsurd liberalism in check. Hersh can go ahead and spin it into a racist image. But just try doing that to the thousands of black veterans who

are proud of their service to their country. We as Americans are proud they honorably served our country. We are thankful, every day. I never noticed Al Sharpton in a military uniform. And heaven help us, if Obama was actually in charge...nothing but a false politician....
report abuse
« mondoSC wrote on Thursday, Oct 15 at 04:27 AM »
Nice rewrite of history. The soldiers who witnessed and put a stop to the shootings at My Lai set in motion the convictions of the perpetrators, just as military investigators unearthed the guilty at Abu Ghraib. Folks like Hersh get leaks of these investigations to report and portray themselves as heroes. Hersh also fails to point out that the U.S. military has a bigger representation of minorities at all levels of leadership than any other public institution. A quantum leap above Congress and the Senate, most notably.
report abuse
« shipley130 wrote on Wednesday, Oct 14 at 06:30 PM »
Was it racist when information was leaked during the Bush years? How about making a racial issue out of a lawmaker letting the world know that the US military was operating inside Pakistan? What a fool.
report abuse
« phillyfanatic wrote on Wednesday, Oct 14 at 03:02 PM »
Now I do not know if the HSun knows that Hersh has been a leftist anti-military gadfly for the NYTimes for decades but his guy is a lunatic when it comes to ever, ever, since Nam , giving our military props and he always thinks that our military should be a Meals on Wheels group ala the President. He has never, never, never approved of any military venture the USA has taken whether it was against Panama, Iraq, or Islamofascism in general. The real reason that the Pentagon is pushing this President, is that our military is dying in Afghan. while this naif in the WH dithers. And just today, there have been charges of racism against the Joint Chiefs if, if , if they continue to chop away at this incompetent CIC. That is an old liberal Dem playbook and here it goes for the Pentagon now. Laughable since much of our military is diverse in color, ethnic distribution and male-female. Hersh should be on the dust bin of history not our military as he always avers they should be.
report abuse
« pacfandave wrote on Wednesday, Oct 14 at 07:38 AM »
Negotiating with the Taliban would serve them two ways. First, it would confirm their terrorist strategy. Second, it would legitimize them as a political entity. Does not the name Stanley Baldwin ring any bells? You cannot negotiate with Stone Age cave-dwellers for whom such concepts as religious tolerance, democracy, gender-equality, intellectual freedom and compromise are spit upon as heresy and the fruits of Western decadence. And as far as the military being at war with Obama over Afghanistan, well, MacArthur was at war with Truman over Korea for the same reasons--no discernible strategy and no moral resolve.
report abuse